Who’s who

The names that recur below. A ban is the association’s penalty and bars a player from competing; a prison term is the court’s.

PersonPart in the caseBanPrison
Wang Tianyi 王天一Bought and sold gamesLife2 years 9 months
Wang Yuefei 王跃飞MiddlemanLife1 year
Hao Jichao 郝继超On the tapes4 years 3 monthsNone
Hong Zhi 洪智2005 championLife2 years 7 months
Zhao Xinxin 赵鑫鑫2007 championLife4 years 9 months
Xie Jing 谢靖2013 championLife2 years 6 months
Xu Chao 徐超2017 championLife2 years 6 months
Liu Dahua 柳大华Accused an officialNoneNone
Dang Fei 党斐Backed Liu Dahua3 yearsNone

Players paid each other to lose

The January 2025 and April 2026 rulings use the same formula: those sanctioned took part in 买棋 and 卖棋, buying and selling games, by way of 行贿 and 受贿, giving and taking bribes. The first notice, in September 2024, says only 买棋卖棋 and 操纵比赛, manipulating competition. Money moved from player to player, in cash, sometimes through intermediaries.

It was not a gambling case, though English write-ups often reach for the word. The charges are offering and accepting bribes as a non-state functionary, and no ruling or indictment describes betting.

Why buying a game paid for itself

Rating points were not just a ranking. Under the system in force at the time they fed appearance and per-game fees, which made them the number a professional was paid on. That produced an asymmetry: a top-rated player gained almost nothing from beating a weaker one and lost a great deal from slipping, while the weaker player earned so little that a fee for losing beat the result. On CCTV, the player Cai Yi 才溢 illustrated the gap as perhaps ¥20,000 a game for a marquee name in a sponsored team event against ¥4,000 for an ordinary master. That rating is gone: the association’s 2026 points ranking took effect on 30 January 2026 and replaced it with a rolling 52-week ranking. The association gave fairer measurement of players as the reason and did not mention the case.

The sport administration’s chess and card centre gave three motives in all: promotion through the grade titles, private division of prize money, and inflating the rating itself. Results were arranged to hit the norms for 特级大师, grandmaster, with players negotiating prices across a national individual championship, and in team events the same trade bought qualification as 运动健将, Master of Sport, which the coverage calls 搭便车, free-riding.

Which is why paying to win a game you would probably have won anyway is not irrational. You are not buying the point. You are buying the rating that sets next season’s fee and the title that outlasts any single event, and against those, tens of thousands of yuan for one game is cheap.

A recording, and a whistleblower nobody could dismiss

In April 2023 recordings of phone calls between two grandmasters, Hao Jichao 郝继超 and Wang Yuefei 王跃飞, appeared online. On them the two discuss buying and selling games, engine cheating, and manipulating rating points. Wang Tianyi is named on the tapes but was not on the calls. The Chinese press named the affair after them: 录音门, the recording gate.

Liu Dahua 柳大华, then 73 and the holder of a one-against-nineteen blindfold record, had been saying for years that opponents’ moves were 相当的精准,和软件一模一样, uncannily precise, identical to the software. On 17 October 2023 he and Dang Fei 党斐 made a 实名举报, a real-name accusation, against Guo Liping 郭莉萍, a deputy director at the sport administration’s chess and card centre. That turned a leaked tape into a governance scandal. Liu was attacked online for it and brought two private criminal prosecutions, one for criminal insult and one for defamation, winning both. Dang Fei is on the list below, at three years.

How the recordings reached the internet is reported by one outlet and confirmed by none: that Hao Jichao made them himself, gave them to Hong Zhi 洪智 after a suspension he considered unjust, and that Hong passed them on. Hong Zhi was himself convicted in 2025 and banned for life the following April.

DateWhat happened
From about 2012Liu Dahua privately alleges engine cheating
April 2023The Hao Jichao and Wang Yuefei recordings appear online
July 2023The association opens a formal investigation
August 2023Wang Tianyi withdraws from the Asian Games, citing health
17 October 2023Liu Dahua accuses a sport official by name
24 July 2024Start date of the bans announced in April 2026
19 September 2024First sanctions: Wang Tianyi and Wang Yuefei, life
12 January 2025Second batch: 41 people
24 September 2025Six grandmasters convicted in Hangzhou
13 April 2026Third batch: 6 people
The spine of the case. Liu Dahua’s earlier private complaints are his own account rather than a documented date.

Two processes, one case

The disciplinary track and the criminal track are separate: the association can only bar a player from competing, and only the court can send one to prison. They ran on different timetables, and the six convicted are six of the forty-nine banned rather than a different group.

The Chinese Xiangqi Association has sanctioned 49 people in three batches: two in September 2024, forty-one in January 2025, and six in April 2026. That is 8 lifetime bans, 37 timed bans and 4 public reprimands. Revocation of the technical grade title accompanies 19 of the 45 bans rather than all of them. Only the three timed bans in the April 2026 notice carry published start and end dates, all running from 24 July 2024; the January notice publishes no dates at all, so when most of those bans expire is not a matter of public record.

The association published almost every name. Where a player also appears on the champion lists, his national title years are in the last column.

PlayerBanNational titles
Wang Tianyi 王天一Life2012, 2016, 2019, 2023
Zhao Xinxin 赵鑫鑫Life2007
Zheng Weitong 郑惟桐Life2014, 2015
Hong Zhi 洪智Life2005
Xie Jing 谢靖Life2013
Xu Chao 徐超Life2017
Wang Yang 汪洋Life2018
Wang Yuefei 王跃飞Life
Shen Peng 申鹏8 years
Wang Kuo 王廓7 years 6 months2020
Sun Yiyang 孙逸阳7 years
Zhao Jincheng 赵金成6 years
Jiang Chuan 蒋川5 years2010
Zhang Shenhong 张申宏4 years 6 months
Sun Yongzheng 孙勇征4 years 3 months2011
Hao Jichao 郝继超4 years 3 months
Liu Junda 刘俊达4 years 3 months
Yu Yixiao 俞易肖4 years 3 months
Cheng Ming 程鸣4 years 3 months
Zheng Yihong 郑一泓4 years
Dang Fei 党斐3 years
Li Shaogeng 李少庚3 years
Zhao Dianyu 赵殿宇3 years
Nie Tiewen 聂铁文3 years
Wu Junqiang 武俊强3 years
Miao Liming 苗利明2 years
Huang Zhufeng 黄竹风2 years
Sun Xinhao 孙昕昊2 years
Yang Ming 杨铭2 years
Xu Chongfeng 徐崇峰2 years
Zhao Wei 赵玮1 year
Lu Weitao 陆伟韬1 year
Yang Hui 杨辉1 year
Li Xiaolong 李小龙1 year
Zheng Yuhang 郑宇航1 year
Ma Tianyue 马天越1 year
Li Aidong 李艾东1 year
Wang Yuhang 王宇航6 months
Zhao Yanghe 赵旸鹤6 months
Cui Ge 崔革6 months
Meng Chen 孟辰6 months
Xie Kui 谢岿6 months
Zhao Ziyu 赵子雨6 months
Cao Yanlei 曹岩磊Reprimand
Huang Wenjun 黄文俊Reprimand
Cai Youguang 蔡佑广Reprimand
Liang Yunlong 梁运龙Reprimand
The 47 the association named. The other two were withheld because they were under 18 when the conduct occurred. Revocation of the technical grade title accompanies 19 of the 45 bans, not all of them.

Hao Jichao, whose recordings started the case, is in the four-year-three-month tier, and was never criminally charged: the sporting penalty is the only one he carries. The end dates that are public all come from the April 2026 batch: Xu Chongfeng’s two-year ban ran out on 23 July 2026, and Jiang Chuan’s five years, announced in that batch and not in January, run to 23 July 2029.

Separately, the Shangcheng District People’s Court in Hangzhou convicted six grandmasters on 24 September 2025 of offering and accepting bribes as non-state functionaries, under Articles 163 and 164 of the criminal law. The Chinese press calls it the sport’s first criminal corruption case.

ConvictedPrison term
Zhao Xinxin 赵鑫鑫4 years 9 months
Wang Tianyi 王天一2 years 9 months
Hong Zhi 洪智2 years 7 months
Xie Jing 谢靖2 years 6 months
Xu Chao 徐超2 years 6 months
Wang Yuefei 王跃飞1 year
Reported from the 24 September 2025 verdict. The terms are 有期徒刑, fixed-term imprisonment; whether any was suspended has not been reported. No judgment text was released: these figures trace to the prosecution’s case, and only Hong Zhi’s was separately reported as a court outcome. Fines were imposed on Wang Tianyi and Zhao Xinxin; no amounts have ever been published.

A third track went nowhere in public. Three officials left the chess and card centre while the case ran: its director Zhu Guoping 朱国平 and its discipline secretary Guo Yujun 郭玉军 in November 2024, and Guo Liping in December. No removal notice mentions this case, and no official has been reported as charged or sanctioned in connection with it.

Why Wang Tianyi was banned for life

The association banned Wang Tianyi for life on 19 September 2024, in its first notice, together with Wang Yuefei, for buying and selling games, and revoked his titles. The notice describes the conduct as long-running and frequent and names no game. A year later the Hangzhou court convicted him of bribery and sentenced him to 2 years 9 months. He pleaded guilty.

He had been China’s top-rated player from 2014 to 2023, known simply as 象棋第一人, the number one. The prosecution charged 22 separate acts of giving bribes totalling ¥942,000, against 2 acts of taking them totalling ¥116,000. Nineteen of the 22 payments ran through Wang Yuefei.

Eight yuan paid for every one received. He was not a weak player selling games he would have lost: he was the best player in the world, buying them.

Hong Zhi was the only one of the six who contested the charge. His appeal was rejected on 10 February 2026, and because he was taken into custody on sentencing day, roughly a year after Wang Tianyi, he will be released considerably later despite the shorter term.

The 12 games prosecutors say were bought or sold

No ruling names a single game. The association’s notices give events and years at most, the court released no judgment text, and the verdict was reported only as counts and totals. The only games named anywhere in the record are in the prosecution’s charges against Wang Tianyi, as the Economic Observer reported them on 13 June 2025 from the 9 May hearing in Hangzhou. Every line below is a charge as that newspaper reported it, not a finding.

They are one man’s charges, not the whole case. At least 37 of the 49 people the association sanctioned appear nowhere in them, and no other player’s charges were reported game by game. In ten of the games he was the buyer, paying an opponent to lose to him; in two he was the seller, paid to lose.

YearEventOpponent he paid to loseYuan
2012National ChampionshipSun Yiyang20,000
2015Gaogang CupShen Peng50,000
2016Yang Guanlin CupXie Jing*16,000
2017Country Garden CupZhao Xinxin153,000
2018Country Garden CupXie Jing, Hong Zhi, Zhao Xinxin*160,000
2018Han Xin CupCheng Ming; Xie Jing*18,000 + 16,000
2019National ChampionshipXu Chongfeng15,000
2019Men’s Team LeagueNie Tiewen, Liu Junda*18,000
2020Men’s Team LeagueNie Tiewen; Liu Junda*28,000 + 16,000
2021Huamu CupShen Peng15,000
Bought: he paid the opponent. Ten games, ¥525,000 in all. * Paid through Wang Yuefei.
YearEventOpponent who paid him to loseYuan
2017National ChampionshipXu Chao100,000
2018Wenling Cup, semi-finalZhao Xinxin16,000
Sold: the opponent paid him, and won. Two games, ¥116,000. Both tables are the prosecution’s charges as reported by the Economic Observer, 13 June 2025; no ruling or published judgment confirms any line.

Ten of the lines have Wang Tianyi paying, and they add up to ¥525,000 of the ¥942,000 he was charged with giving; the reporting does not itemise the rest. The two lines where he was paid, ¥100,000 from Xu Chao and ¥16,000 from Zhao Xinxin, add up to exactly the ¥116,000 he was charged with taking. Xu Chao won that 2017 championship. Every player named in the list is also on the association’s sanctions list above.

The same report describes the first game. Sun Yiyang, then 17, had Red and was ahead for a time, then made a run of errors and resigned at move 88; Wang Tianyi went on to win that 2012 championship. The move-by-move account is an unnamed observer’s, quoted by the paper.

All of it rests on one newspaper. We read the report in two reprints, on Sina Finance and Tencent News, which agree on most lines; the two league seasons appear only in the Sina reprint. We have not seen the list in any other outlet’s account of the hearing. Wang Tianyi pleaded guilty to the charge, but the verdict as reported does not say which of these games the court accepted.

The cheating nobody charged

Engine cheating runs through every account of this affair and appears in no ruling. It is the substance of the recordings, of Liu Dahua’s accusation, and of the press investigations, while the findings cite only bribery and the buying and selling of games. Nothing published resolves it either way.

What exists is testimony. Liu Dahua says that at a league match in Ordos in October 2018 he was standing beside Hao Jichao’s game against a teammate of his own when he twice heard a voice call a move, 卒5平4, pawn five to the fourth file, and that Hao then played it. He suspected smartwatches as the capture device, and says that at an earlier fixture where watches were collected before play, Hao lost two games. This is his account, and no finding confirms any of it.

Xu Yinchuan, who won six national titles and three world titles and is named in none of the three notices, is quoted as saying 有了软件以后,就感觉自己的棋跟软件比就根本没法下, that once the software existed his own play felt unplayable measured against it. He is describing what engines did to a professional’s confidence in preparation rather than accusing anyone, which is worth keeping distinct.

Tao Hanming, the 1994 champion, spoke out against software cheating in January 2016 and retracted the next day, saying he had spoken out of turn after drinking. A friend later told Jiemian the drink was cover for pressure. Which version to believe is the kind of thing a disciplinary finding settles, and none did.

No result has been struck from the record

No ruling says which individual games were bought. What was revoked is the personal technical grade, the 特级大师 or 大师 rank, which is a title conferred on a player rather than a tournament result. No championship or team title appears to have been annulled, and the champion lists on this site are unchanged. Ratings are a special case: none were struck, but the rating itself was replaced when the 2026 points ranking took effect on 30 January 2026.

So the names stay on those pages with the finding beside them. Dropping them would assert something the rulings do not: that the games themselves were not real.

Where the banned players are now

The notices give the same reason for every name, buying and selling games, and none says which games. The players searched for most stand like this. Wang Tianyi is the only one who has spoken: on 21 October 2025 he published an apology on his personal account, his first public statement since the sentence, saying he could finally let go of the obsession with being first under heaven, that he had once told himself buying games was something everyone in the profession tacitly accepted, and that people would see a better version of him.

PlayerBanPrison
Wang Tianyi 王天一Life2 years 9 months
Zheng Weitong 郑惟桐LifeNone reported
Zhao Xinxin 赵鑫鑫Life4 years 9 months
Wang Kuo 王廓7 years 6 monthsNone reported
Jiang Chuan 蒋川5 years, to July 2029None reported
Sun Yongzheng 孙勇征4 years 3 monthsNone reported
Meng Chen 孟辰6 monthsNone reported
All but Meng Chen also had their technical grade title revoked; Wang Kuo’s 2020 national title stands. Apart from Wang Tianyi’s apology, Chinese-language searches in October 2026 for each name (latest news, response, livestream, Douyin, comeback) found no public statement after the ruling. That is a statement about those searches, not proof of silence.

Where the sport is now

The league came back. The 2025 national men’s league ran its preliminary from 30 July 2025 and opened the main stage in Harbin on 3 August, with revised eligibility rules and a reformed format: 25 teams, ten advancing to a double round-robin, four boards played in two waves of two, and a blitz tiebreak deciding drawn matches. Whether the format was designed against collusion is not stated anywhere official, but a match that cannot end level is harder to arrange.

Thirty-seven of the bans expire. Eight do not. The 2025 national championship was won by Wang Yubo 王禹博, the first title since Xu Yinchuan’s in 2009 that comes with no asterisk on it, and the 2025 world title left China for the first time.

Every national champion since 1956Every world champion since 1990

Sources

All of it is Chinese-language reporting, listed so a reader who reads Chinese can check it rather than take our word for it.

What it coversSource
The April 2026 rulingsXinhua, Caixin
The January 2025 batch of 41China News Service, China Daily
Wang Tianyi’s life ban, September 2024National Business Daily
The verdict and the six sentencesYangtse Evening Post, Sina Sports
Hong Zhi’s refusal to plead guiltyTencent News
Appearance fees and the motivesCCTV
Liu Dahua’s account; how the tapes spreadJiemian
The fullest timeline of the affairGuancha
The 12 charged games, 13 June 2025Economic Observer, via Sina and Tencent
Wang Tianyi’s apology, 21 October 2025Jiemian
Both notices, with Jiang Chuan’s datesXinhua, Yangtse Evening Post
The 2026 points ranking and its reasonBeijing Daily

Several claims here rest on thinner ground than the rest, and the text says so where they appear: five of the six sentences trace to the prosecution rather than a released judgment, the 12 games are one newspaper’s report of the charges, all of Liu Dahua’s testimony and the Xu Yinchuan quotation are single-sourced accounts, the route the recordings took to the internet is one outlet’s investigation, the officials’ departures are not officially tied to this case, and the absence of any annulled result is inferred from silence rather than stated in a ruling.