Which endgames win and which draw

Each result is the grade Chinese endgame manuals give that kind of ending (the scale is below), shown on one position of that kind. In a tricky win (巧胜) the material normally draws and this position wins; in a hard win (难胜) the board shows the setup that holds. The full defence (士象全) is two advisors and two elephants. Soldiers are named by how far they have come: a bottom soldier (底兵) stands on the last rank, a low soldier (低兵) one rank short of it, and a high soldier (高兵) further back, where it can still come down on the palace. Each name in the table opens that position in the practice sets.

The manuals grade an ending on a six-step scale. The table uses four of the steps: a 必胜 or 必和 ending shows as 例胜 or 例和, which understates the result and never misstates it.

GradeWhat it claims
必胜 (bì shèng)Wins from any position with this material
例胜 (lì shèng)Wins with standard technique
巧胜 (qiǎo shèng)Normally a draw; wins only from particular positions
难胜 (nán shèng)Hard to win, which is not the same as a draw
例和 (lì hé)Draws with standard defensive technique
必和 (bì hé)Draws from any position

Soldier endgames

MaterialResultKey idea
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHigh soldier vs bare generalWin (例胜)A soldier short of the last rank beats a bare general. The red general does half the work by holding a file the black general cannot cross.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardBottom soldier vs bare generalDraw (例和)On the last rank a soldier can only move sideways, and on its own it cannot force mate.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHigh soldier vs one advisorDraw (例和)One advisor is enough to hold a single high soldier.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHigh soldier vs one advisor, soldier in the palaceTricky win (巧胜)A high soldier against one advisor is normally a draw, but it wins when the soldier already stands in the palace and Red is to move.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHigh and low soldier vs two advisorsWin (例胜)A high and a low soldier together beat two advisors.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo high soldiers vs two advisorsWin (例胜)Two advisors alone cannot hold two high soldiers.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo high soldiers vs two elephantsWin (例胜)Two elephants alone cannot hold two high soldiers either.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo high soldiers vs advisor and elephantDraw (例和)The mixed pair holds where two advisors or two elephants lose: the advisor covers the palace, the elephant the approach.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo high soldiers vs cannonWin (例胜)A cannon with nothing to jump over cannot hold off two high soldiers.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardThree high soldiers vs horse and two advisorsWin (例胜)Three high soldiers also beat a horse with two advisors.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardThree high soldiers vs cannon and two elephantsWin (例胜)Three high soldiers also beat a cannon with two elephants.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardThree high soldiers vs full defenceWin (例胜)Three high soldiers break the full defence, which a lone chariot cannot.

Horse endgames

MaterialResultKey idea
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse vs one advisorWin (例胜)Against one elephant instead, the same horse only draws.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse vs one elephantDraw (例和)A lone elephant holds against a horse: it can switch flanks faster than the horse can cut it off.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse vs one elephant, elephant caught on one flankTricky win (巧胜)With the elephant caught on one flank and Red to move, the horse cuts it off from the other side and wins.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse vs crossed soldierDraw (例和)A black soldier across the river is enough to hold off a lone horse.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo horses vs full defenceWin (例胜)Two horses beat the full defence; a chariot, worth more than both, does not.

Cannon endgames

MaterialResultKey idea
楚 河 漢 界MistboardCannon vs bare generalDraw (例和)A cannon needs a piece to jump over before it can capture, so with nothing on the board to use it cannot mate.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardCannon and advisor vs two advisorsWin (例胜)With its own advisor as a screen, the cannon beats two advisors.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo cannons vs two elephantsDraw (例和)Two cannons alone cannot break two elephants.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo cannons and advisor vs full defenceWin (例胜)Add one advisor and the two cannons beat the full defence.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardCannon and full defence vs full defenceDraw (例和)A cannon backed by its own full defence still cannot break the full defence.

Chariot endgames

MaterialResultKey idea
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs defence missing one elephantWin (例胜)A chariot beats the defence once one elephant is missing.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs full defenceDraw (例和)The strongest piece on the board cannot break the full defence on its own.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs full defence, elephants on the edgeTricky win (巧胜)The full defence draws only from a sound setup. With both elephants stranded on the edge, the chariot wins.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs horse and two advisorsWin (例胜)With two elephants in place of the advisors, the horse can build a drawing fortress.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs horse and two elephantsDraw (例和)The fortress: the horse on the elephant point in front of the general and the two elephants protecting each other. Held exactly like this, the chariot cannot get through.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs cannon and two advisorsDraw (例和)A cannon and two advisors hold against a lone chariot.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs cannon and two advisors, advisors at homeTricky win (巧胜)With both advisors on the back rank and the cannon in front of the general, the chariot wins.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardTwo chariots vs chariot and full defenceDraw (例和)A chariot behind the full defence holds off two chariots.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot vs horse and cannonHard to win (难胜)Black holds with the cannon directly behind its own general and the horse off every point one chariot move attacks. Move the cannon one point sideways and Red mates in 12.

Horse and soldier, chariot and cannon

MaterialResultKey idea
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse and soldier vs defence missing one elephantWin (例胜)Horse and soldier beat a defence that is missing one elephant.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardHorse and soldier vs full defenceDraw (例和)Against the full defence the same horse and soldier only draw. The fourth defensive piece is the whole difference.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot and cannon vs chariot, Red chariot on the middle fileWin (例胜)Chariot and cannon beat a lone chariot when the red chariot holds the middle file.
楚 河 漢 界MistboardChariot and cannon vs chariot, Black chariot on the middle fileDraw (例和)The black chariot holds the middle file level with the red chariot and cannon, low enough to guard the foot of the file, where the mate 海底捞月 is played. One rank higher and Red mates in 17.

The results follow the Chinese Wikipedia list of standard results (象棋勝和定式), which cites 金启昌 and 杨典, 象棋残局胜和定式 (2008). Rows it does not grade follow English Wikipedia. The positions are ours, and every result was checked against the exact results of chessdb.cn, the Chinese chess cloud database, for that exact position.

Try one: horse against a lone elephant

A horse against a lone elephant is a draw as a rule: the elephant switches flanks faster than the horse can cut it off. In this position the elephant is stuck on one side and Red moves first, and that is enough. The tablebase gives Red mate in five moves. The first move decides it: find the point that keeps the elephant from getting back across.

楚 河 漢 界Mistboard
Red to move and mate in five.
Play it out

One point can turn a draw into a win

楚 河 漢 界Mistboard
Draw: horse and two elephants in their fortress.
楚 河 漢 界Mistboard
Win: the same pieces, one elephant on g10.

In the first diagram the horse stands on the elephant point in front of the general and the two elephants protect each other, and the chariot cannot get through. In the second, the elephant from g6 stands on g10, and the chariot wins. It works the other way too: pull the three high soldiers back one rank and their win over the full defence is gone, because two of them now stand on points a black elephant can reach.

Set up your own endgame

Any position can be practised the same way. Set it up in the board editor, choose whether you are playing to mate or to hold the draw and which side you take, and press Play it out.

Open the board editor

Look it up in the tablebase

For the exact result of a position, press Analysis board in the editor and open the Opening explorer under the board. Once few enough pieces are left, it shows the Tablebase: every legal move with its exact result from chessdb.cn, and how many moves to mate.

How far the tablebase reaches: chessdb.cn lists 8,705 xiangqi endgame tables, about 102 trillion positions in all (its table list, read 2026-10-07). Most have eight or nine pieces. Forty have twelve, and one has thirteen: three soldiers with a full defence against a full defence. Horse and cannon against a horse, both sides with a full defence, is also thirteen pieces and is in no table, which is why it is missing from the table above: the manuals grade it 例胜, and neither the database nor an engine search has confirmed it.